Link[1] Systems and system failure â testimony to PDG 24th November 2010
Citerend uit: Jake Chapman
Publication info: 2010
Geciteerd door: David Price 10:40 PM 9 August 2015 GMT
Citerank: (10) 352281Changes required across many different policy areasObesity has to be seen as not just a technical, food, physical activity or healthcare problem but a challenge for what sort of society is being built. Small, incremental, publicity-driven (i.e. social market-based) changes might suit the existing balance of policy interests, but a more extensive, co-ordinated, cross-sectoral action would be more effective.1198CE71, 352797Definitive evidence is often difficult to obtain"When dealing with complex systems it is rarely possible to obtain the sort of evidence that would be required in science, engineering or clinical trials. As things stand, the overall evidence base on how to tackle obesity is limited, and what evidence there is on effective approaches is skewed towards short âvisibleâ interventions at an individual and consumer level." [1]118FF4888, 352799Need to appreciate and incorporate multiple perspectivesA second dimension of complexity requires an appreciation of the different perspectives used by agents and agencies within the system (pluralism). Most of the population, including many experts and scientists, are not able to dis-identify from their own perspective sufficiently to be able to appreciate other people's perspectives fully. Until all the key perspectives are incorporated into a study then any analysis will be partial and any intervention likely to fail. [1]118FF4888, 352800Desire for solutions undervalues real improvementsWhen dealing with complex human systems it is necessary to focus on improvements, not solutions. Sustainable change takes place slowly and as the result of co-operative action by large numbers of agents and agencies within the system. [1]118FF4888, 352802Institutional inertiaIn most human activity systems a change in the functioning of the whole system requires a significant number of people within the system to change; they may have to change some or all of their habits, behaviour and values. [1]118FF4888, 399558Changes required across many different policy areasObesity has to be seen as not just a technical, food, physical activity or healthcare problem but a challenge for what sort of society is being built. Small, incremental, publicity-driven (i.e. social market-based) changes might suit the existing balance of policy interests, but a more extensive, co-ordinated, cross-sectoral action would be more effective.1198CE71, 400056Institutional inertiaIn most human activity systems a change in the functioning of the whole system requires a significant number of people within the system to change; they may have to change some or all of their habits, behaviour and values. 118FF4888, 400077Definitive evidence is often difficult to obtainWhen dealing with complex systems it is rarely possible to obtain the sort of evidence that would be required in science, engineering or clinical trials. As things stand, the overall evidence base on how to tackle obesity is limited, and what evidence there is on effective approaches is skewed towards short âvisibleâ interventions at an individual and consumer level.118FF4888, 400079Need to appreciate and incorporate multiple perspectivesA second dimension of complexity requires an appreciation of the different perspectives used by agents and agencies within the system (pluralism). Most of the population, including many experts and scientists, are not able to dis-identify from their own perspective sufficiently to be able to appreciate other people?s perspectives fully. Until all the key perspectives are incorporated into a study then any analysis will be partial and any intervention likely to fail.118FF4888, 400080Desire for solutions undervalues real improvementsWhen dealing with complex human systems it is necessary to focus on improvements, not solutions. Sustainable change takes place slowly and as the result of co-operative action by large numbers of agents and agencies within the system.118FF4888 URL:
|