These notes will be published to Debate Graph as usual.

Attendees : 

• Jeff Orgel
• Joe Andrieu
• Dave Crocker
• Mei Lin Fung
• David Price
• Anna De Pulford
• Matthew Schutte
• Mister Dan
• Katherine Kern
• John Philpin

Useful Links :

The Google Doc that has emerged form Last weeks workshop

Debate Graph

Our Google Group

Actions

• JP will circulate notes (thanks to Mei Lin for her copy - duly merged) (these are they!)
• JP will find a time for a demo and a deep dive into Debate Graph with David Price
• David Price / Mei Lin will connect any other graphs in the Debate Graph system that relate to Lost Identity

Topics Covered …

• Intro To Yeti From Anna De Pulford
• Last Weeks Workshop - Joe Andrieu
• Red Cross Update- Dave Crocker
• Debate Graph Overview - David Price
• 211 Connecticut - Katherine Kern

Welcome To New Member Anna De Pulford (Yoti)

YOTI – a digital id platform putting ownership back in hands of individual – role is in the foundation supporting initiatives in the field of identity eg challenges that people face, ethics and promoting stds – introduced by Doc and Joyce – who are also are ‘Guardians of YOTI’.

Yoti Guardians ….

Yoti Guardians are influential individuals who ensure that Yoti always seeks to do the right thing, and that we are transparent about what we are doing and why. Guardians will bring their expert, independent perspectives and skills to three main responsibilities:

• Making sure Yoti optimises its products, services and partnerships to make life simpler for its user community.
• Ensuring Yoti stays consistent with its mission to build trust and give the user control of their personal data.
• eporting any breaches of trust and representing any concerns shared by a significant percentage of the user community. … a guardian is there to call Yoti out on decisions that are no consistent with heh – can call us out.

Workshop - Joe Andrieu

Half Day Tuesday and All Day Wednesday

Engagement model around Maria Sofia

EIRS – Emergency Identity Recovery System (JP - see notes on Google Doc)

Lifecycle engagement model

Context setting 

draft text - maria sofia profile is a wip

⁃ skeleton

⁃ draft text

⁃ ERIS visualized - Emergency Recovery Identity System

Comments

Matthew – intricacies clarified

John Philpin – 1^st day very good – fan of process

Mei Line - life cycle engagement model is important

Jeff Orgel ….

• attended remotely - effort and process 
• second day harder to engage
• Request - better audio  and video feeder future events
• Watching awareness of remote viewers – really helpful
• Second day harder to track audio
• Great process – improve audio

Red Cross and Socal fires- Dave Crocker

Finding out how ID is used by Red Cross – is not using formal systems – will ask – but any use of it is minimal. 

Facilitate processes leading to dealing with agencies

for most part red cross will ask for

- records / use will be minimal

will facilitate processes

- eg replacing pills

- or by connecting pharmacy / or redirecting to emergency room

Assignment to Socal fires

Finding out how ID is used by Red Cross – is not using formal systems – will ask – but any use of it is minimal. 

Facilitate processes leading to dealing with agencies – Red Cross will help get prescriptions by directing to Pharmacy or ER. 

Jeff Orgel – ground of story line – fault tolerance with supporting systems – hardware in place – do they fall back to spiral notebooks – are there any systems in SoCal or same challenges as in PR – how 

Debate Graph - David Price

Collaborated with Mei Lin in the past

Gates Foundation global health – healthy birthrate and development with 300 scientists and foundation members thinking thru factors from molecular level to national policy

Has social networking built in – commenting, adding posts within context

Strength – complex problem with many dimensions – interlink goals and objectives of stakeholder groups – explore arguments and identify actions – graph becomes an external representation of group’s understanding – in an open and transparent way – surfacing learning and capturing different perspectives and insights – in a single graph – provides all to keep track of the process. Graph is set up so all can participate – usually work in parallel – email, conversations. Requires more attention but rewards it. 

Gates foundation – conceptual framework with 900 factors, 120 interventions, 3000 research papers – difficult for anyone to hold the work in their heads – make it explicit – could identify new interventions – understand inter relationships – eg negative feedback loops were discovered. Working with a structure difficult to hold in head – can make connections that are difficult to find and identify. 

Process is like Mediation – creates a safe space to surface contentious issues – see it as part of a larger whole.

Joe Comment

… added deliverables – familiar with inspiration – bubbles and arrows – use it for work breakdown structure – I understand what needs to go into mindmap – struggling for LIG debategraph – what should bubbles be? Guidance about how to organize?

David Price Response : 

easy to create node types; can surface anything and not worry bout structure – how the structure – can be kaleidoscopic way – may not know what it might interconnect to, sharing it in DG allows connections to emerge

Encourage and experiment – the structure emerges

Cross linking – material surfaced in one context can be shared in another context

211 Connecticut - Katherine Kern

• Part of United Way and done in other states
• Library of resources – to help those who need help – very helpful and willing to share information – keep a large national database for disaster response – able to fill in and take overflow calls for other states
• Identity – doesn’t come up very much – requests for information are about birth certificates – “Real ID Act” makes drivers license meet TSA stds – requires birth certificates – have utility bill with address on it
• Birth certificate coming
• She was interested in identity issues
• Guardianship form for parents to fill out 

Comments

Mei Lin

medicare and Medicaid in Puerto Rico

Joe

attributes could be used to identify someone – how privacy could be leaking

If you ask someone on identity, they will focus on their own context – when sharing info in emergency – don’t realize it could be used – identity information is exposed in situation

Katherine

 when giving blood – there is a lot of information collected – HIPPA compliance

Dave

historically very different from blood donations and emergency – now Red Cross has a goal of “one red cross” so will talk to the blood folks

Disaster folks facilitating

Anna

this is where we are really interested – UNHCR released a framework for GDPR legislation – ethics of decision making in disaster situations