Must retain Marxian labour theory of value
The notion of 'ongoingness' is useful for analyses of waste-value relations, but only if a Marxist theory of value as congealed labour is retained.
"Lepawsky and Mather have recently drawn on actor network theory to make a case in this journal that analytical attention should be placed on processes of wasting and valuing as a way to look beyond the end of commodities' initial lives. This can be done, they contend, by exploring how commodities are physically transformed into new objects to the point where their constituent elements are no longer recognisable as what they once were and through how waste is 'performed' in different ways in different times and places. Although their paper rightly emphasises economic continuity, we suggest that their approach nevertheless ultimately fetishises commodities' form and that their claim that '[i]n following 'e-waste' qua waste, we were bringing its reality as waste into existence' represents an idealist approach to waste. By way of contrast, we seek to retain their nuanced conception of ongoingness but without abandoning analysis of the movement of value - conceived of here in the Marxist sense of congealed labour - through the chain of product destruction, the processing of products' constituent parts, and their reuse through incorporation into new products."
 
Source: Herod, A., G. Pickren, A. Rainnie, and S. McGrath-Champ. 2013. ‘Waste, Commodity Fetishism and the Ongoingness of Economic Life’. Area 45 (3): 376–82. doi:10.1111/area.12022.
CONTEXT(Help)
-
StEP - Scholarly Debates »StEP - Scholarly Debates
Debates/Issues »Debates/Issues
Appropriateness of analytical concepts »Appropriateness of analytical concepts
Must retain Marxian labour theory of value
Herod, A. »Herod, A.
Pickren, G. »Pickren, G.
Rainnie, A. »Rainnie, A.
McGrath-Champ, S. »McGrath-Champ, S.
+Comments (0)
+Citations (0)
+About