comments

If the Tunisian revolution won, it was won in the street, not online

Can We Please Stop Talking About 'Twitter Revolutions'?

In our search for a single cause, we're much more likely to settle on an "new technology" explanation rather than something as dull as a great many of the participants were unemployed or wearing socks. Not only do "Twitter revolution" explanations mean more page views, but they fulfill some deterministic urge within us -- the dual promises of technology and modernity. There was as much breathless enthusiasm about the power of the telegraph to do good as there is the Internet. InTom Standage’s wonderful book on the growth of the telegraph he says these reactions are amplified by what he terms "chronocentricity," "the egotism that ones own generation is poised on the very cusp of history."

When we glorify the role of social media we are partly glorifying ourselves. Some of us are not only praising the tools we know and love and use every day, but also the tools we build and have stakes in. To proclaim a Twitter revolution is almost a form of intellectual colonialism, stealthy and mildly delusional:  We project our world, our values, and concerns onto theirs and we shouldn’t. We use Twitter and so must they. In our rush to christen the uprising, did we think to ask Tunisians what they wanted to call their revolution?
RELATED ARTICLESExplain
⌅
Technology: Oppressor or liberator?
⌃
ICT's capacity to spread democracy?
⌃
Cyber-utopianism
⌃
Cyber-utopians overstate the revolutionary potential of the Internet
⌃
Social media do not help revolutions to happen or succeed
■
If the Tunisian revolution won, it was won in the street, not online
↳
'Democracy isn't just a tweet away'
↳
The internet is neither necessary nor sufficient for a revolution
↳
The seed of nearly all revolutions is dissatisfaction
↳
Social media did amplify the revolt. It doesn't have to be all or none
□
Social media failed to shape mainstream media coverage of Tun. events
□
There were revolutions before Facebook
□
Twitter did not bring down Ahmadinejad in 2009
□
Twitter had scant internal significance in Moldova 2009
□
Graph of this discussion
Enter the title of your article


Enter a short (max 500 characters) summation of your article
Enter the main body of your article
Lock
+Comments (0)
+Citations (1)
+About
Enter comment

Select article text to quote
welcome text

First name   Last name 

Email

Skip