We cannot say that "this" gene causes "that" mental trait.

"... research now reveals such mind-boggling complexity that nothing definitive can be said about ‘this causing that’."

"For instance, in the realm of psychiatry there is no known gene or clear genetic variants for around 97% of all the mental disorders now contained in the current DSM and ICD. And even where genes may be implicated in disorders like bi-polar disorder and schizophrenia, research now reveals such mind-boggling complexity that nothing definitive can be said about ‘this causing that’.

A central complicating factor is our growing understanding of epigenetics. Modern genetics now broadly accepts that it is virtually impossible to understand how our biology works outside the context of our environment. To put the new genetics in the simplest terms, virtually no neurological and psychological disorders have been demonstrated to result from the mutation of a single gene. Rather they are now known to involve molecular disturbances that implicate multiple genes and the signals that control their expression.2In other words, the popular idea that so-and-so gene causes so-and-so mental trait has been surpassed by the notion that it is interactions between our genes and their environment that actually shape us."

(emphasis added.)

No known biological causes. / CEP / 2014.

RELATED ARTICLESExplain
ISPS-US Moving Forward Map
Moving Forward
How can we move forward?
Use the Moving Forward Matrix
Change Public Opinion
Promote Positive Change
What do we want the public to know?
We cannot say that "this" gene causes "that" mental trait.
The idea of "chemical imbalance" is a myth.
"Anti-psychotics: most are major tranquilizers."
Psychiatric drug withdrawal brings its own dangers
The 13 Unrecognized Facts at CEP.
Disorder labels are contested: e.g. "schizophrenia"
It should be about choice.
This definition of psychosis
"Shock “Treatment” Is Not Safe and Provides Little If Any Benefit"
"There is no such thing as 'abnormal psychology.'"
Make people aware of online ICD-10, Section V.
People's Personal Stories
The "fundamental flaw" in neuroscience research. (2016)
The idea that "madness and misery" are medical conditions is contested
United Nations Statement Criticizes Medicalization of Depression ...
Graph of this discussion
Enter the title of your article


Enter a short (max 500 characters) summation of your article
Enter the main body of your article
Lock
+Comments (0)
+Citations (0)
+About
Enter comment

Select article text to quote
welcome text

First name   Last name 

Email

Skip