Reprogramming is consistent with free will

The reprogramming argument fails to show that robots lack free will. The claim that nothing programmed could be conscious relies on 2 false assumptions: 1) programmed behavior is entirely predictable, 2) programmed behavior lacks all spontaneity.

The Putnam argument

"The phonograph-record argument: a robot only 'plays' behavior in the sense in which a phonograph record plays music. When we laugh at the joke of a robot, we are really appreciating the wit of the human programmer, and not the wit of the robot. The reprogramming argument: a robot has no real character of its own. It could at any time be reprogrammed to behave in the reverse of the way it has previously behaved. But a human being who was 'reprogrammed' (say, by a brain operation performed by a race with a tremendously advanced science), so as to have a new and completely predetermined set of responses, would no longer be a human being (in the full sense), but a monster. . .

The first argument ignores the possibility that robots learn. . . . The second argument, like the first, assumes that 'programmed' behavior must be wholly predictable and lack all spontaneity" (H. Putnam, 1975, p. 396-7).

Reference

Putnam, Hilary. 1975. Robots: Machines or Artificially Created Life? Mind, Language, and Reality: Philosophical Papers Volume 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp 386-407. Originally in The Journal of Philosophy, Vol. LXI, November 1964, pp 668-91.
RELATED ARTICLESExplain
Artificial Intelligence
Can computers think? [1]
No: computers can't have free will
Computers only exhibit the free will of programmers
Preprogrammed robots have no psychological states
Reprogramming Argument
Reprogramming is consistent with free will
Reprogammed humans retain free will
Reprogrammed robots can be spontaneous
Robots can always be arbitrarily programmed
Graph of this discussion
Enter the title of your article


Enter a short (max 500 characters) summation of your article
Enter the main body of your article
Lock
+Comments (0)
+Citations (0)
+About
Enter comment

Select article text to quote
welcome text

First name   Last name 

Email

Skip