Computers can't do otherwise

An agent's actions are free if and only if the agent can do otherwise than peform them. The agent is free only if it can change its goals—but only dialectical reasoning allows an agent to change its goals, and machines are not capable of this.

26

Joseph Rychlak 1991.


An agent's action is free if and only if he could have done otherwise than perform that action. Understanding 'could have done otherwise' in teleological terms, this means that an agent is free if and only if he can change his goals. It is predicational behavior that allows one to change his goals, and thereby act freely. Since machines are not capable of predicational behavior, they are not free.

The Rychlak Argument
 
"The predicational model allows for this alternative [an agent's having done otherwise, all circumstances remaining the same], because the person in continually taking a position on life-conforming to what is the case or altering events based on what is eventually affirmed in one's line of reasoning.... The determination here is based, not on material-efficient, but on formal-final causation. The dialectically reasoned human being is always-from the birth of cognition!-affirming a course of predicated behavior that could have gone in opposition to the course it actually took. Inanimate objects, well described extraspectively in material/efficient-cause terms, never arrange such grounds for the sake of which their existence carries forward" (J. Rychlak, 1991, p. 104).

References

Rychlak, Joseph. 1991. Artificial Intelligence and Human Reason (New York: Columbia U. Press, 1991.)
RELATED ARTICLESExplain
Artificial Intelligence
Can computers think? [1]
No: computers can't have free will
Computers can't do otherwise
Joseph F. Rychlak
Computers don't choose their own rules
Free will has infititude beyond deterministic limits
A determined machine can still have free will
Computers only exhibit the free will of programmers
Free will derives from multi-level structure
Free will is a decision-making process
Humans also lack free will
Random selection produces free will
Graph of this discussion
Enter the title of your article


Enter a short (max 500 characters) summation of your article
Enter the main body of your article
Lock
+Comments (0)
+Citations (0)
+About
Enter comment

Select article text to quote
welcome text

First name   Last name 

Email

Skip