Images are cognitively penetrable SupportiveArgument #960

Images are cognitively penetrable, in that they can be altered in various ways by what a subject thinks. They can't be explanatory primitives as they break down into simpler parts depending on context.
For example, in a biological context, an image of a rose is seen as a composition of petals, sepals, leaves and stems, whereas in an artistic context the images is seen as a composition of colour patches, shadings and edges.

Zenon Pylyshyn (1981).

Cognitively penetrable: a mental phenomenon is cognitively penetrable if it can be accessed and altered by other thought processes. For example a belief that the cat is on the mat is cognitively penetrable, because it can be altered by further information that the cat is actually a dummy.

According to Pylyshyn, those phenomenon that are cognitively penetrable are generally explained in terms of symbolic rule governed processes and operate on the more basic, cognitively impenetrable components.

Cognitively impenetrable: a mental phenomenon is cognitively impenetrable it cannot be accessed or altered by other thought processes. For example, a person’s perception of red is cognitively impenetrable, because it can’t be changed to a perception of green.

According to Pylyshyn, cognitively impenetrable phenomena are primitive explanatory concepts, because they remain basics throughout changes of context.
PAGE NAVIGATOR(Help)
Map HomeArtificial Intelligence
IssueCan computers think? [1]
PositionNo: computers can't understand images [5b]
OpposingArgumentImages represented by filled cells in an array
SupportiveArgumentImages are Quasi-pictorial representations
SupportiveArgumentImage Psychology
SupportiveArgumentImages are primitive, functional components of thought
OpposingArgumentImages aren't primitive explanatory concepts
SupportiveArgumentImages are cognitively penetrable
OpposingArgumentImpenetrability doesn’t isolate basic elements
OpposingArgumentImpenetrability doesn't argue against image theory
OpposingArgumentPenetrability doesn't affect format
AdvocacyZenon Pylyshyn
CommentsAdd a comment
Metadata

Entered by:- David Price
Entry date (GMT): 8/22/2006 11:48:00 AM
Last edit date (GMT): 12/13/2007 12:26:00 AM
Incoming cross-relations: 1
Outgoing cross-relations: 0
Average rating: 0 by 0 users