Why do we see an entropy gradient? Issue #103810

We find ourselves in an observable universe in which entropy increases consistently in one direction, thereby showing time asymmetry - an arrow of time. Yet the vast majority of underlying dynamical processes are time-symmetric. How to account for this? Two broad approaches are considered here.
Note that the important issue is not whether we regard the entropy slope as positive or negative. If it is a matter of convention which direction counts as 'positive' time, then it follows that whether entropy is regarded as increasing or decreasing is likewise a matter of convention (see citation below).
PAGE NAVIGATOR(Help)
Map HomeThe Arrow of Time
IssueThe physics of time
PositionThe thermodynamic arrow
IssueWhy do we see an entropy gradient?
PositionAsymmetric boundary condition
PositionAsymmetric physical processes
Citations


Author: Huw Price - Head of the Center for Time, University of Sydney
Cited by: Peter Baldwin 0:53 AM Friday 15 April 2011 GMT
Also cited at: 100641, 103807, 103810, 104152, 104155, 105365
URL: http://www.bourbaphy.fr/price.pdf
Excerpt / Summary
"By the end of the nineteenth century, on the shoulders of Maxwell, Boltzmann and many lesser giants, physics had realised that there is a deep puzzle behind the familiar phenomena described by the new science of thermodynamics. On the one hand, many such phenomena show a striking temporal bias. They are common in one temporal orientation, but rare or non-existent in reverse. On the other hand, the underlying laws of mechanics show no such temporal preference. If they allow a process in one direction, they also allow its temporal mirror image. Hence the puzzle : if the laws are so even-handed, why are the phenomema themselves so one-sided ?"
Entropy gradient not entropy increase

Author: Huw Price - Head of the Center for Time, University of Sydney
Cited by: Peter Baldwin 1:40 AM Monday 2 May 2011 GMT
Also cited at: 100641, 103807, 103810, 104152, 104155, 105365
URL: http://www.bourbaphy.fr/price.pdf
Excerpt / Summary
"If it is conventional which direction counts as positive time, then it is also conventional whether entropy increases or decreases. It increases by the lights of the usual convention, but decreases if we reverse the labelling. But this may seem ridiculous. Doesn't it imply, absurdly, that the thermodynamic asymmetry is merely conventional ?

No. The crucial point is that while it's a conventional matter whether the entropy gradient slopes up or down, the gradient itself is objective. The puzzling asymmetry is that the gradient is monotonic it slopes in the same direction everywhere (so far as we know)."
p.121
CommentsAdd a comment
Metadata

Entered by:- Peter Baldwin
Entry date (GMT): 4/12/2011 7:44:00 AM
Last edit date (GMT): 5/2/2011 1:37:00 AM
Incoming cross-relations: 1
Outgoing cross-relations: 0
Average rating: 0 by 0 users