Debategraph home

Sorry - the map you tried to view has either been deleted or access is denied.

Featured maps

Peace in the Middle East
Help The Independent and the Debategraph community map and evaluate the contentious issues and potential paths to long-term, sustainable peace in the Middle East.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Intellectual Property in the Digital Age
Mapping the debate around on Intellectual Property in the digital age as part of the National Center for Technology and Dispute Resolution's Cyberweek 2009.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Future of Newspapers?
The global financial crisis has brought the newspaper industry's structural problems to the fore as it responds to the changing competitive environment in the digital era. What does the future hold for newspapers and for the journalism they enable and support?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Changing sport for the better?
Tell The Independent what changes would you like to see in your sport?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Africa: A Continent in Crisis
A debate map beginning to explore the issues that must be addressed (and how) to restore Africa's position (and that of its people) in the world.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Abortion
Mapping the arguments on all sides of the abortion debate. Under what circumstances, if any, should abortion be permitted?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Copenhagen: what's happening?
Help The Independent explore the current state of play in the build up to the UN Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen in December 2009.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Future of Corporate Learning?
A debate map exploring the business case for corporate learning based on the initial dialogue at the Canary Wharf workshop on 9th December 2008.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

To be or not to be...
A light-hearted map of Hamlet's existential dilemma (Act III, Scene I), to commemorate the 444th anniversary of Shakespeare's birth on 23 April 1564.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Faith or Reason?
A debate map starting to explore questions arising from the contemplation of faith and reason.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Open Source or Proprietary Software

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Power of Information Taskforce - Recommendations
The POIT was set up to advise and assist the UK government on delivering benefit to the public from new developments in digital media and the use of citizen- and state-generated information.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

What should Labour do next?
A collaboratively editable, interactive debate map for The Independent exploring what the Labour Party can do to improve its electoral prospects in the next General Election.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

National Security of the Republic of Kosovo

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Obama in Berlin
A debate map exploring the issues and positions addressed by Barack Obama in his speech in Berlin on 24th July 2008.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Road Congestion
Analysing the issues around, and potential responses to, the projected increases in road congestion in the UK.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Who Should Be the Next Philippine President?
A debate map starting to examine the Presidential elections in the Philippines in 2010, created by Llonard Yap.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Michael Jackson Death Investigation
Exploring the issues and timeline around the death of Michael Jackson in June 2009 – from all perspectives.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Open Government Data
30 Open Government advocates gathered in Sebastopol, Califfornia in December 2007 to develop these 8 fundamental principles of open government data.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Scientific research on monkeys
One of the debates from the Open Up! series produced by the Democracy and Participation programme at nef (the new economics foundation) – and funded by the Wellcome Trust.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Compression Thinking
Population growth squeezes all of us on a planet whose resources are finite. To not only survive, but improve quality of life, we must become much smarter using what we have. For practical, effective action, work organizations critical to Compression must greatly "compress" their learning cycles.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Australia's Great Debate on Asylum Seekers and Refugees

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Which way are the UK newspapers voting and why?
What UK general election results are the national newspapers advocating - and why?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Housing Policy in the UK
A debategraph beginning to explore the issues around housing policy in the UK; seeded with the arguments from Matthew Taylor's RSA blog post.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Open Government
Redacted transparency proposals from the White House's Open Government Brainstorming on Transparency—drawn from the Office of Science & Technology Policy's blog.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Dificultades en el uso de software libre en ONGs
En tu opinión, ¿por qué muchas organizaciones sociales no utilizan casi las herramientas de software libre?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Public consultation on folic acid
The FSA public consultation solicited comments from the public at large and interest groups on the best way to increase the folic acid intake of women of childbearing age so as to reduce incidence of NTDs.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Private vs. Public Health Care
Health care is a necessity for all people. In Europe and North America, citizens enjoy the highest quality of health care provision, with life expectancy reaching the late 70's. Is private or public funded health care preferable, and why?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Drugs Policy in the UK
A debate map exploring and building on the detailed findings of the RSA Commission on Illegal Drugs, Communities and Public Policy's review of UK policy on the use and abuse of illegal drugs.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Free our Bills
A map of the debate around mySociety's Free our Bills! campaign to encourage Parliament to publish its proposed new laws with semantic XML mark up.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Education Policy in the US
A map exploring education policy in the US—starting with the effectiveness (or otherwise) of the standards-based education reforms.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Manual de Comunicación 2.0
Todo lo que los profesionales de la comunicación 2.0 están compartiendo en Internet suman un manual vivo de la comunicación 2.0. ¡Añade tus aportaciones!

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Problem Solving
A map beginning to explore various ideas on how to improve problem solving, started by Thomas Teepe.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Nuclear Politics
Since the Trinity test in New Mexico in 1945, Russia, the UK, France and China have joined the US as nuclear weapon states—with India, Pakistan, Israel and North Korea also thought to possess a nuclear weapons capability. Help us map the issues around civil and military nuclear proliferation.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Open Government Brainstorming
Redacted proposals from the White House's Open Government Brainstorming on Transparency, Participation and Collaboration led by OSTP's Open Government team.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Responding to Iran's nuclear ambitions
Examining the current diplomatic crisis over Iran's pursuit of full nuclear fuel cycle technology, including the ability to enrich uranium.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Can Computers Think?
A long term project with AI theorists and philosophers to bring Robert Horn's brilliant and pioneering debate map of 50 years of philosophical argument about the Turing Test and the possibility of computer thought up to date.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Should Drugs be Legalised?
A map on global drugs policy issues; starting with the debate around the legalisation of drugs. Would drug legalisation benefit or harm society?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Visualizing the Prime Ministerial Debates
The Independent is using Debategraph to map UK Prime Ministerial Debates in the build up to the election on 6th May 2010.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Future of Public Service Broadcasting in the UK
What role, if any, should public service broadcasting play in the UK in the 21st century?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

What should Obama do next?
A series of debate maps for The Independent exploring the question of what Obama and America should do next on the main policy issues facing the new administration after the inauguraton on 20 January 2009.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Íslensk álitamál
Should Iceland join the European Community?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Role of Prison in Society
A debate map beginning to explore the issues around the role of prision in society in the 21st Century.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Legal Status of the War on Iraq
A map, in collaboration with Austhink Consulting, exploring the legal status of the Coalition's war on Iraq—starting with the arguments advanced by the 43 legal experts and the Liberal MP Greg Hunt in the Australian media on the eve of the war.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

New York Watershed
A Cornell Law School Water Law Clinic project exploring how the communities that supply New York City's water maintain proper water quality for a global city while surviving as living, working places.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Collective intelligence
A debate map created by Eduoard Nau, starting to explore the spectrum of collective intelligence.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Is the Institution of Marriage at Risk?
A debate map beginning to explore the instiution of marriage, it's benefits, the media portrayal of marriage, and the issures around same-sex marriages.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Linked Data
Visualizing Linked Data (see LinkedData.org).

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

techniques de démocratie
une chose est de favoriser le débat entre citoyens, une autre chose est de rendre officiellement contraignant le fruit de ce débat pour l'exercice du pouvoir "du peuple, par le peuple, et pour le peuple" ;-)

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Take Back the Tech! on Online Pornography
Part of the Take Back the Tech! campaign calling for everyone - especially women and girls - to take control of technology to end violence against women.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Copenhagen Summit Map
Watch and help us map some of the COP15 sessions as they are being streamed live from the Bella Center in Copenhagen at: CopenhagenSummitMap.org.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

CL2M - Closed Loop Lifecycle Management

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

1914-1945 : démocratie, guerres, totalitarismes

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Draft Flood and Water Bill
A map by an interdisciplinary team at Durham University, UEA, and Oxford University starting to explore whether and how the draft flood and water bill can address current and future flooding in the UK.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Millennium Development Goals
A map starting to explore the issues around the eight Millennium Development Goals.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Prosperity without Growth
Exploring the relationship between prosperity and economic growth: and seeking to develop a new vision of the capability of humanity to flourish within the ecological limits of a finite planet.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Lower Manhattan Project
The Lower Manhattan Project is assembling a multidisciplinary team to examine the impact of the current economic crises on energy, the environment, and security.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Digital Publishing?
Map "publishing" -- A suggested alternative to traditional digital publishing in an era of Cloud-based services, the Semantic and Social Webs and touch-screen enabled, network-connected devices.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Poverty and Welfare Politics and Policy in U.S.
This is a project of the students of POLS 275 at Western Illinois University. Faculty sponsor: Sharon Chanley, Ph.D.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Opium Production in Afghanistan
A map exploring the issues around the production of Opium in Afghanistan, seeded from The Independent's Big Question

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Joy of Christmas
A debate map to help parents answer the questions of any precocious children who might be erring dangerously on the naughty side of nice this Christmas (with thanks to Dr Larry Silverberg).

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Latvijas ekonomika un politika
Šis ir/bija mēģinājums radīt vizuāli pārredzamu un idejiski saprotamu katri par tiem cilvēkiem, institūcijām un procesiem, kas risinās Latvijā tik ļoti saistītās divās sfērās - ekonomikā un politikā.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Is Human soul mortal or immortal?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Les nouveaux programmes d'Histoire-Géo au collège
Ils seront mis en oeuvre à la rentrée 2009pour la 6e.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Ktimatologio

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Drug Manufacturers and the Profit Motive
Big pharma has lost touch with the reason they exist - to find safe and effective ways of dealing with disease. Instead, we are sickeningly reminded with each ad they produce for their latest "breakthrough" drug how many side-effects and contraindications it has...

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Core Principles of Public Engagement
Seven recommendations reflecting the common beliefs and understandings of those working in the fields of public engagement, conflict resolution, and collaboration.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

CSC
Se faire une opinion sur le captage et stockage du carbone

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Doug Engelbart Institute
Conceived by Douglas Engelbart as a vehicle for broad-based collaboration to explore how we can dramatically boost our ability to solve complex, urgent problems on a global scale collectively.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Resources/u23/header_cnn_com_logo_int.gif

Amanpour CNN
Christiane Amanpour's live global interview program ran on CNN from September 2009 to April 2010 with the aim of setting the agenda for a new global conversation. Debategraph worked with Amanpour to map this conversation online – producing a map of around 3,000 ideas.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Simplified SharePoint Governance
A "living" SharePoint Governance map, developed by Australian SharePoint guru Paul Culmsee, of cleverworkarounds.com, to illustrate the free Seven Sigma Debategraph SharePoint web part.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Climate Change
Mapping the causes, consequences and potential responses to climate change—in collaboration with, amongst others, The Independent, the Open University and the MIT Center for Collective Intelligence.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Sport and Genetic Enhancement
Harvard philosopher Michael Sandel's concerns about the application of genetic technology to sport, as expressed in his recent Open University Ethics Bites philosophy podcast.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Resources/u23/globalfinancialcrisis2.jpg

The Global Financial Crisis
A debate map starting to explore the immediate and long-term causes, consequences and potential responses to the emerging global financial crisis.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Flash vs Ajax
Rich Internet Application developers are in a constant debate as to whether Flash or AJAX is a better and stronger approach to the solution.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Klimaforum09 – People's Climate Summit
Klimaforum09 is the global civil society counterpart of the official UN Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen 7–18 December 2009.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Declaration on Public Services 2.0
In November 2009, an EU Minsterial Declaration will spell out EU eGovernment policy for the next three years. Help us co-create a bottom up open Public Services 2.0 declaration alongside it.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Politics and the media
The debate arising from Tony Blair's final Our Nation's Future lecture as Prime Minister on the systemic problems between politics and the media in the 21st Century.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Intelligent Design
A debate map starting to explore the issues, positions and arguments around the theory of Intelligent Design.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The G-20 London Summit 2009
Help The Independent and the Debategraph community think through and visualize what the Group of Twenty (G-20) should do at the London Summit 2009 in April 2009.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Momentum
Monitoring, Coordinating and Promoting the European Union eParticipation Projects and Initiatives.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Whataboutery in Ireland
The Slugger O'Toole community is starting to chart the many forms and dimensions of ‘whataboutery’ in Northern Ireland.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

New York City Watershed Program Issues

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Gulf Oil Spill Disaster
A map of links about and human response to the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico that began April 20 2010.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Contemporary Business Issues
A map exploring Contemporary Business Issues started by Jennifer Cleaver a student at Harper Adams University College.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Bob Quick's Resignation
Bob Quick, Britain's head of counter-terrorism, resigned after inadvertantly exposing documents about an ongoing anti-terror operation to press photographers on his way into Downing Street.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

ID cards and databases
Mapping the debate around the proposed introduction of a biometric identity system in the UK. What is the government's rationale for the system? And does this rationale stand up to detailed scrutiny?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Seasteading
A debate map exploring the issues around seasteading—i.e. building structures for permanent living on the ocean's surface.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Parental Force and Children
A map exploring the debate around the use of force by parents against children (following the amendment of New Zealand law in 2007 to remove the legal defence of "reasonable force").

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Aquinas - Man's last end
A debate map setting out and starting to examine the argument presented in St. Thomas Aquinas' Summa Theologica Prima Secundae Partis, Question 1.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Outputmanagement (OPA)

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Sorrow of War - Bao Ninh
A map by students at Victoria Shanghai Academy in Hong Kong starting to explore the non-linear narrative of Bao Ninh's novel set in the Vietnam war.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Telemedicina

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Future of Royal Mail

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Twenty20 Cricket
Is the rapid emergence of Twenty20 cricket a positive development for the sport as a whole?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

U.S. Alternative Energy Industry?
A map created by Sean Costigan, of the GlobalEESE network of energy and environment experts, to help debate and share ideas and research about the future (with support from the US Departments of Energy and State).

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Prison Architecture
A map by Grace Pang exploring the controversy around the architecture of prisons.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Predicting Market Price and Volatility
A debate graph, created by Andrew Willis, starting to explore the potential for accurate prediction and forecasting of market prices.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

¿Como mejoramos el Casco Histórico de Vitoria-Gasteiz?
¿Como mejoramos el Casco Histórico de Vitoria-Gasteiz?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

¿cómo organizo un Centro Universitario?
El objetivo que se pretende es definir unas líneas generales que deberían guiar la organización y gestión de un Centro Universitario.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

is rap music real music?

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Food Insecurity
Converging trends such as land conversion, irrigation failure, extreme weather conditions threaten food security. Crop production dropped while prices escalated.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Realising the Potential of Social Media
Tim Davies's analysis of the factors that hold organisations back from realising the potential of social media to make them more efficient, participative, collaborative and accountable.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

The Crisis in Gaza
Help The Independent and Debategraph explore the causes of the crisis in Gaza, the legal status of the attacks, the ceasefire, and the potential ways forward.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

Debategraph Feedback
What should we improve next? Spotted a bug? What needs to be simpler or clearer? Thought of a feature that you would like to see? This is the place to let us know.

Go to map >>Link or embed >>

MAP KEY

SEARCH TOOL

SEARCH RESULTS

MY BOOKMARKS

Roll over key for explanations of element types.

Debate Previewer

1. Select search option
Any word
All words
Exact phrase

2. Enter search terms

Search results are displayed here. They are grouped by map, with maps ordered by number of matches. Within maps, matching items are color coded and grouped by element type.

Move the mouse over the menu to view more information about each element. Click to open the map at the selected element.

Note that the matching term or phrase may be in the 'expanded text' of an element rather than the heading or concise texts visible in the previewer on this page. Expanded texts can be accessed by opening the map and selecting View 1 of the element using the Debate Dashboard.

Your bookmarks will be displayed here after you have logged in. Items are color coded and grouped by map, with maps listed alphabetically.

Move the mouse over the menu to view more information about each element. Click to open the map at the selected element.

Any map you visited is automatically added to your bookmarks. Note the delete symbol on each of your bookmarks.

To create a new map:

Give the map a descriptive title—typically different from the debate question(s), which are added to the map as Issue elements.
Choose whether you want the map to be public or private. Public maps can be accessed by any user from search results or external links. Private maps can only be accessed by people you invite and are not searchable. A private map can be made public at any stage.
Click Create new map.
Click Go to your new map to begin building the debate map.

Step 1: Enter map title (max 70 chars)

Step 2: Set map access
Public
Private

Step 3:

Step 4: